The Good, the Bad and the Dangerous | Protagonist Talk

Protagonist talkI’ve been feeling awful inspired to talk about some protagonists lately and there’s so many possible discussions that I wanted to start out basic. So, today we’re talking about the good, bad, and the dangerous parts about our main characters in books. This all started while reading various reviews, talking with friends and my own reading/writing experiences, and from that I’ve come to the conclusion that we hold our protagonists to almost ridiculous standards. In a way, it makes sense, a strong lead can make or break a book, but let’s discuss the different aspects of those leads.


Because of these standards, many novels have fantastic protagonists that we all love to read. They’re strong, independent, possibly witty/funny and typically have pretty relatable traits. These standards are also pushing writers to improve their skills and create these characters with lead like personalities, but not make them perfect and still try to make their character unique to others.

These expectations also help us bloggers because we know what qualities make a great protagonist and if one doesn’t live up to how we feel that certain character should be, it forces us to possibly adapt or it gives us an interesting topic to blog about. Sometimes it’s nice to be able to say that we found a unique and interesting lead, even if we didn’t like them.


How many times have you read a book where the lead is a timid young adult girl who has to grow into her own shoes and end up saving the world? Quite honestly, the answer to this is typically a lot. Having such high standards causes lots of repetition in protagonist traits and it can get tiring to feel like you’re reading the same character over and over.

Even though we might not like to admit it, we all secretly hold our protagonists to this standard. Sometimes, I’ll even catch myself comparing one character to my favorite character from a completely different book and it takes some effort to give that individual character their own chance.

I highly appreciate when I come across a protagonist that I find completely different from anyone else that I’ve read before and that’s the kind of character that stick in my head, however, authors can reach a point where their protagonist is too out of this world and they become unlikable, which just conforms protagonists to this invisible standard even more.


Authors like to mess with this fine line and one of the most recent examples I can think of is Kiera Cass’s Eadlyn. When I first started reading The Heir, Eadlyn was one of my least favorite characters I’ve ever read, and if she didn’t go through some of the transformation that she did I probably would’ve stopped reading the book.

However, this danger zone is what makes unique and memorable characters. Writing good characters nowadays is finding that perfect balance of good and bad qualities and finding a way to perfectly tread the waters of the danger zone.


I invite you guys to join the discussion! What do you feel like makes a strong protagonists? When has an author gone too far with a character or do you think that’s possible? Do you find yourselves giving protagonists an invisible standard to follow or do you truly try and judge each character as their own?

Personally, I now realize that I do need to try harder to judge each character as their own because every author deserves to have their character shine for who they truly are. I also hope that this will create some new and interesting topics to discuss and analyze in my book reviews. Thanks so much for trying out this new type of post with me!



3 thoughts on “The Good, the Bad and the Dangerous | Protagonist Talk

  1. I can’t remember on what blog it was but someone once wrote that it is ok to not like a character. You can’t possibly like every character that you come across and every since I read that, I’ve found myself more receptive to characters or at least, making an effort to not immediately judge a character.

    It’s inevitable that you compare characters–I do it all the time though I try really hard not to. Lately I’ve been trying to keep the character contained within their story and review them based on the plot/situations they go through. I’ve read a lot of characters lately that I don’t necessarily like but I can respect their purpose and character growth as I read since I focused on understanding them individually instead of in the big world of characters.

    Which is why I think we’ve created this “invisible standard”. If you read a lot of high fantasy novels like I have been lately, you kinda read the same character over and over again because what other options are there really? You either have the heroine who is thrust into the rebellion or the one who is in it from the get-go. Regardless, they have to be involved in the rebellion somehow or else it makes for a boring book because everything is just happening around them **coughTheSelectioncough**. They don’t get much of a choice sometimes I think.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I just stumbled across your blog and I loved this post! Such an original post! I definitely agree that we all judge characters too closely to our other favourite characters, but it’s just so difficult not to! Personally, I always feel as though I relate better with female protagonists, which is so annoying because I really don’t want to be that kind of reader! I guess it’s because for me the most important value of a protagonist is being able to relate to them!
    Love your blog!
    Ayesha xx

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s